Baby Toys & Gifts

For the littlest ones. Our baby gifts, toys, and keepsakes make thoughtful presents for every new arrival, with plush, rattles, books, and milestone keepsakes. Perfect for a baby shower gift, a newborn welcome, or a first birthday.

29 products
Cat Teether Mushie teether Blush Cat Teether Bonjour Fete - Party Supplies
Cat Teether Mushie teether Stone Cat Teether Bonjour Fete - Party Supplies
Cat Teether
Add
$12.99
Bunny Teether Mushie teether Bunny Teether Bonjour Fete - Party Supplies
Bunny Teether Mushie teether Bunny Teether Bonjour Fete - Party Supplies
Bunny Teether
Add
$12.99
Bath Boats Mushie toys Original Bath Boats Bonjour Fete - Party Supplies
Bath Boats Mushie toys Bath Boats Bonjour Fete - Party Supplies
Bath Boats
Add
$12.99
Mushie wooden farm puzzle in FSC-certified wood with non-toxic paint
Infographic of the Mushie wooden space puzzle: FSC-certified wood, non-toxic paint, easy-grasp pieces
Wooden Puzzle
Add
$24.99
Mushie wooden abacus in muted tones with beads on sturdy rods
Infographic of the Mushie wooden abacus: FSC-certified wood and non-toxic paint for counting and color sorting
Wooden Abacus
Add
$29.99

The right baby gift is sweet, soft, and made to keep, and this collection gathers thoughtful options in one place. Shop plush toys, rattles, books, and milestone keepsakes, plus pretty presents for the parents-to-be. It all works for a baby shower gift, a newborn welcome, a first birthday, or a holiday present for a little one.

Pick a soft plush or a keepsake for the main gift, then add a book or a milestone set to round it out. Beautifully packaged, baby gifts feel extra special. For shower decor and tableware, see our baby shower decorations.

FAQs

Thoughtful baby shower gifts include soft plush toys, keepsakes, books, milestone sets, and pretty everyday items the parents will use. Something soft and made to keep, like a plush or a keepsake, paired with a practical item is always appreciated. Beautiful packaging makes any gift feel special.

For a newborn, soft plush, swaddles, books, and milestone keepsakes are favorites. For a first birthday, a special plush, a keepsake, or a first-birthday book makes a lasting gift. Choose something soft, safe, and made to keep, and add a card for a personal touch.

A baby keepsake is a gift made to be saved and remembered, like a milestone set, a first-year keepsake, a special plush, or a personalized item. These gifts mark the early days and become treasured mementos, which makes them popular for showers, births, and first birthdays.